RentRedi collects the rent. Keystead keeps the books.
RentRedi is a genuinely good rent-collection app — payments, autopay, late fees, screening. But its accounting came later. Keystead was built accounting-first: AI lease parsing, bank feeds that match rent to tenants automatically, and CPA-grade output at tax time.
No credit card required · cancel anytime · setup in under 10 minutes
Keystead vs RentRedi, honestly
| Feature | Keystead | RentRedi |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $29/mo up to 10 units, $79/mo up to 50. 14-day free trial, no card. | Start plan $5/mo; Grow plan $29.95/mo (or $12/mo billed annually). Unlimited units on all plans. |
| Core focus | Accounting-first: books, rent matching, categorization, and tax output, with operations built around them. | Rent collection first: payments, autopay, late fees, and tenant credit reporting are the heart of the product. |
| AI lease parsing | Drop a PDF — every term extracted with confidence scores and citations back to the document. | Lease documents are stored and e-signed; terms are entered manually. |
| Bank feeds & rent matching | Plaid feeds on both sides: incoming rent auto-matches to tenants — including rent paid outside the app by Zelle, ACH, or check. | Rent paid through RentRedi is tracked automatically; the bank-feed integration pulls debit transactions into the expense workflow. |
| Bank rules & transfer detection | QuickBooks-style rules by payee and amount, plus transfer detection between your own accounts. | AI-powered receipt categorization; full double-entry books are available through the REI Hub add-on at extra cost. |
| Schedule E export | Aligned line-by-line to the IRS form, on every plan. Built by a CPA founder. | Schedule E and P&L reports included on all plans. |
| Maintenance / work orders | Work orders with status, assignees, estimates, and actual costs on every plan. | Maintenance requests and vendor management on the Grow plan and above (not the $5 Start plan). |
| Tenant screening & listings | Not yet — Keystead focuses on what happens after the lease is signed. | Applications, tenant-paid screening, one-click listings, and tenant credit reporting. A real strength. |
| Mobile app | iOS app on the way; the web app is fully responsive today. | Mature landlord and tenant mobile apps on iOS and Android. |
RentRedi plan details and pricing from rentredi.com/pricing and the RentRedi help center, checked June 2026: Start $5/mo, Grow $29.95/mo monthly or $12/mo billed annually, Pro by quote; REI Hub accounting available as a paid add-on. Features change — confirm current details on each vendor's site.
Who should use RentRedi — and who should use Keystead
RentRedi makes sense if your main problem is getting rent paid. Its tenant app, autopay, automatic late fees, flexible payment options, and credit reporting are built to make tenants pay on time through the platform — and unlimited units at $12/month billed annually is hard to beat on price. It also covers listings, applications, and tenant-paid screening, so the leasing funnel lives in one place.
Keystead makes sense if your main problem is the books. Self-managing landlords rarely get every tenant onto an app — rent shows up as Zelle transfers, ACH deposits, and the occasional paper check. Keystead reads your real bank feed and matches each payment to the right tenant automatically, categorizes expenses with QuickBooks-style rules, and produces Schedule E-ready output. Rent collection is a feature; clean books are the product.
Accounting-first vs accounting added on
RentRedi has been expanding its accounting suite, and credit where due — receipt categorization and a bank-feed expense integration are real improvements. But the architecture tells the story: payments made through RentRedi are tracked automatically, while the rest of your financial life gets layered on, and full double-entry books live in the REI Hub add-on at additional cost.
Keystead starts from the bank feed because that's where the truth is. Every transaction in your property accounts — rent in, expenses out, transfers between accounts — flows through one pipeline: rent auto-matches to tenants, debits auto-categorize via rules you control, and transfers are detected so they never inflate your numbers. The lease terms that drive it all (rent amount, due dates, deposits, late fees) come from the AI lease parser, not from an evening of data entry. One system, no add-on, no double-keying.
The Schedule E story, from a CPA founder
Both products offer a Schedule E report. The difference is what feeds it. Keystead's founder is a CPA, and the categorization engine was designed backwards from the IRS form: insurance lands on line 7, mortgage interest on line 12, repairs on line 14, taxes on line 16, utilities on line 17 — per property, all year long, automatically. A Schedule E report is only as good as the categorization underneath it, and Keystead's is done by rules and AI rather than by you, in January, from memory.
If your CPA has ever sent back a list of "uncategorized" transactions with questions, you know exactly what this is worth — both in fees and in February evenings.
What it actually costs
RentRedi: the Start plan is $5/month with rent payments and core accounting but without applications, screening, listings, or maintenance requests. The Grow plan — their most popular — is $29.95/month, or $12/month billed annually, with unlimited units. The Pro plan is quote-based. Tenant screening is tenant-paid ($39.99–$49.99), and full double-entry accounting via REI Hub costs extra.
Keystead: $29/month for up to 10 units and $79/month for up to 50, custom above that — with the AI lease parser, Plaid rent matching, bank rules, Schedule E export, work orders, and the resident portal all included. No add-ons to reach full books. Start the 14-day trial with no card, upload one lease, connect one bank account, and compare the output side by side.
Common questions
What's the real difference between Keystead and RentRedi?+
Where each product starts. RentRedi is rent collection first — payments, autopay, late fees, tenant screening, and credit reporting — with accounting features layered on, and full double-entry books available through the REI Hub add-on. Keystead is accounting-first: AI lease parsing, Plaid bank feeds with automatic rent-to-tenant matching, a QuickBooks-style rules engine, and Schedule E output aligned to IRS line items, with rent and maintenance operations built around those books.
Is RentRedi cheaper than Keystead?+
Often, yes. RentRedi's Start plan is $5/month and its Grow plan is $12/month billed annually ($29.95 month-to-month), with unlimited units. Keystead is $29/month for up to 10 units and $79/month for up to 50. If price per unit is your only criterion and you mostly need rent collection, RentRedi wins that comparison. Keystead's pitch is the hours: the AI does the lease entry, rent matching, and expense categorization that you'd otherwise do by hand.
My tenants pay by Zelle and check, not through an app. Which tool handles that better?+
This is Keystead's home turf. Because Keystead reads your actual bank feed through Plaid, rent is matched to the right tenant no matter how it arrives — Zelle, ACH, wire, or a deposited check — by amount, payer name, and your custom rules. RentRedi works best when tenants pay through the RentRedi app; payments made outside it need to be logged manually, though its bank-feed integration does pull in expense transactions.
What is RentRedi better at than Keystead?+
The tenant-facing payment experience. RentRedi has mature iOS and Android apps for landlords and tenants, flexible payment options including cash, rent reporting to credit bureaus, tenant screening, and listing syndication — and unlimited units at a flat price. If your priority is getting tenants to pay on time through an app, RentRedi is genuinely good at that. Keystead's resident portal covers rent and maintenance, and our iOS app is on the way.
Can my CPA work with Keystead's output?+
That's the point of the product — Keystead's founder is a CPA. Expenses categorize into Schedule E-aligned categories (insurance to line 7, mortgage interest to line 12, repairs to line 14, taxes to line 16, utilities to line 17), transfers between your accounts are detected so they don't distort income, and the year-end export is per-property and CSV-ready. Most CPAs can drop it straight into the return.
Rent collection is table stakes. Clean books are the edge.
Connect your bank and watch a month of transactions match and categorize themselves. If it doesn't beat your current setup, you've lost nothing.
14-day free trial · no credit card · cancel anytime